By John C. Dvorak
Why aren't standard-cell rechargeable nickel hydride batteries available in the United
States? They've been sold in Japan for over two years. When you discover the benefits of
these batteries, you immediately see the end of the Energizer bunny, finally.
Anyone who uses a high-resolution digital camera knows that standard disposable
batteries can cost almost as much as film and developing for a regular camera. Taking
about 40 megapixel shots on any CCD digital camera would chew up a complete set of
alkaline batteries. Some time back I discovered that rechargeable nickel cadmiums last
longer, because they can deliver quick amps with more efficiency than alkalines. Then
Olympus quietly started shipping nickel hydride batteries with its cameras, and they
lasted twice as long as anything I'd ever used and were rechargeable, too.
Ken Hawk, the president of 1-800-Batteries, is a big fan of these new nickel hydride AA
batteries. Using a low-resolution camera, he did a quick study of their usefulness, and
the results were astonishing (see the table below). Only nonrechargeable lithium batteries
can outperform them. He also tested a standard nickel cadmium and a plain carbon battery,
both of which gave fairly poor results. My experience with nickel cadmium batteries was
better--not worse--than with alkalines. Hawk had the camera flash on for all his pictures,
which probably changes some parameters. He also took pictures at 10- second intervals,
which affects the way the batteries respond.
Environmental concerns over cadmium could eventually eliminate nickel cadmium batteries
anyway. And since the nickel hydride battery is so far ahead of the rest of the pack, who
cares? The nickel hydride battery has an energy density two to three times that of nickel
cadmium and no memory effect. The battery works to minus 20 degrees Celsius, and the
documents I've seen indicate that nickel hydride battery technology isn't even fully
optimized yet.
The calculation of cost for nickel hydride batteries in the table is for 100 recharges.
Hawk says the industry knows that nickel hydride batteries can easily last through 500
recharges. I've seen data indicating that 1,000 charges are possible. This drops the cost
per 10,000 pictures to 70 cents! I'm convinced that the industry doesn't want people to
know about these batteries. I seriously doubt you'll be seeing them on a rack in the
grocery store anytime soon. Do the math: It's like buying 1,000 alkaline batteries for
less than 10 bucks. Imagine what this does to the lucrative disposable-battery business.
Even when nickel hydride batteries are sold with cell phones and laptops, we are subtly
led to believe that the increased battery life has more to do with the technology of the
product than with the battery itself. The promotion of this revolutionary battery
technology has been quite low-key. Here's another kicker: You can fully recharge nickel
hydride batteries in less than 2 hours.
So now I wonder where the D, C, and AAA nickel hydride batteries are? Mostly in Japan.
As far back as January 1996, Toshiba rolled out the first complete line of standard cells
and other Japanese battery makers have followed. This event was essentially hushed up in
the U.S. market. The big-name American battery companies have avoided this market-killing
technology for obvious reasons. The only manufacturer of standards cells in the United
States is Harding Energy in Michigan. Duracell makes a nickel hydride battery pack sold
for industrial applications but doesn't make standard cells. Try Personal Solar Inc. for Japanese cells and special
nickel hydride chargers. 1-800-Batteries has the AA camera batteries. These batteries are
susceptible to damage from overcharging and require a special charger (one that will do a
complete charge in about 2 hours is only $35).
It's time we woke up to the new reality of battery technology and got off the
disposable treadmill, which is filling garbage dumps. You digital camera users need
rechargeable nickel hydride batteries right now.